Sometimes the road home is smooth. Sometimes it’s rough. Even though I live in CT, I fly out of Newark, NJ rather than Bradley. It sounds like it might take more time BUT when going to Bradley there is a process.
The drive to Hartford can take anywhere from 1 - 2 hours depending on the day. I park in the parking garage because I want to make the quick walk over to the airport. It’s a little bit more expensive than offsite parking, but the convenience is worth it. The Hartford airport is very small. The gas, travel, and parking 3 for days usually cost me $120.
The travel to Newark, if planned properly, can be easier, though it’s also a process. Three trains. Metro-North is a 15 minute walk from my front door. The ride to Bridgeport is $2.75 and takes 30 minutes. Amtrak from Bridgeport to Newark can be as little as $20 each way. With travel insurance the total can be $30 each way. Bridgeport to Newark takes 2 hours 15 minutes. The tram directly to the airport terminal takes 5 minutes. This cost is covered by the Amtrak ticket. Total cost of round trip travel, when planned properly, $67.
The flight itself is also less expensive. To fly from Hartford (BDL) to Tampa (TPA) is $205 at the time of this writing. The flight from Newark (EWR) to Tampa (TPA) is $138, also at the time of this writing. These are round trip numbers when scouring for cheap flights. My flight from Newark to Tampa was only $100.
The only real wildcard with the train is flight changes. In the past I’ve had to scramble to change a train when a flight is leaving 1 - 2 hours earlier than expected. I’ve never missed a train due to a delayed flight but it’s been close.
I now plan 3 hours on either side (arrival and departure) just to make sure there is some flexibility if things go haywire.
If the flight is changed to an earlier time at Bradley, I drive over earlier. If the flight is delayed coming home the car will always be waiting in the parking garage. If the flight is delayed it costs more but the car will still be there.
On the last trip from Tampa I decided to take the earlier train back from Newark. My flight landed at 3. I was supposed to be on the 6 pm. This train would have brought me back home for 9:05 pm. If I could catch the earlier, the 4:12 pm, I would be back home for 7:15 pm. Called Amtrak to change it. Was on the phone for 15 minutes.
They tried to change the ticket but didn’t, initially. They lost the slot for the $20 ticket I paid for and said I had to pay the conductor $5 when I got on the train. No problem. I hung up and waited for the app to refresh my ticket.
Nothing. 15 minutes to train arrival. Tried to refresh my ticket. No change. Still reads 6:00 pm. 10 minutes to train arrival. No change. 5 minutes to train arrival. Nothing.
I call again. I’m put into the call tree. I finally get to the point where I can enter my reservation number BEFORE it will let me talk to another human being. Even though the app has not refreshed the automated system lets me know that the reservation has been changed from 6:00 pm to 4:12 pm … THE NEXT DAY!! It’s now 4:10. The train arrives at 4:12. I’m still on hold. I jump on the train. It takes off.
I’m already on the train. They are now coming around to scan tickets. I’m thinking I might get kicked off the train. The app is not refreshed. Even if it did refresh, I’m on the wrong train. Just as they are about to get to me there is a bit of commotion.
The train stops at the NJ Penn Station. There is some police activity on one of the trains ahead of us and we are stopped for an undetermined amount of time.
The problem with the train travel from Newark is that the schedule is very tight. The 4:12 train from Newark arrived at Bridgeport at 6:37. The Bridgeport train to my home station arrived at 6:47. There was a 10 minute window. The 6:00 pm train from Newark arrived at Bridgeport at 8:22. The Bridgeport train to my home station arrived at 8:31. Minimal room for error is allowed. Hence the aforementioned 3 hour flexibility window.
The app is still not refreshing. If they do decide to scan tickets, I might still get kicked off the train. We are at NJ Penn Station for 1 hour. No movement. People start leaving the train to take The Path. This is the local train that takes you from New Jersey Penn Station to the World Trade Center Station. I would then have to take another train to Grand Central to catch the metro-north back to CT.
The guilt begins. Why didn’t you just stay on the 6:00 pm? By this time 90% of the passengers have left the train to catch The Path or take an Uber.
I got off the train to take The Path but I couldn’t get my card to work on the turnstile. As I turn around in frustration, I notice the train that was immediately in front of us for the last hour and a half has moved.
I jumped back on the train and it took off. We were only 15 minutes ahead of the 6:00 pm train. Everything felt clear. Most of the passengers were gone. I would be in Bridgeport early enough to make the 8:31 connection. All was good.
Just then a voice came over the speakers. “Thank you for staying with us through all the delays. Next stop is New York Penn Station. Due to the time taken up on the tracks, a new crew will be taking over. We will be rescanning tickets. Thank you for your patience.”
It was like a game of cat and mouse.
My ticket was still a mess. I tried to call Amtrak to see if I could get it adjusted BUT we were now underground and I had no service. Jumping on the Amtrak Wi-Fi didn’t help. My phone is not set up for Wi-Fi calls.
What now? Get off the train and hope to catch the Metro North back to CT? Stay on the train and plead the case to the conductor? Even if they dumped me off at the next stop I could’ve made it back.
I decided to stay on and take my chance with the conductor. I wasn’t trapped in Jersey anymore. I was in Metro-North land. The last train from Bridgeport to the home station was 11:43. I would get home at 12:13 in the morning. It was miserable and late but it would have worked.
I saw the conductor and stated my case. He scanned my ticket. The app still hadn’t refreshed. The reservation scan pulled up my information. It looks like the agent over the phone had deleted everything. There wasn’t even a 4:12 ticket for the next day. He laughed it off and let me stay on the train.
Got to Bridgeport at 8:05 rather than 6:37 or 8:22. Caught the 8:31 back to my home station and walked the 15 minutes. The 6:00 pm from Newark to Bridgeport flew through without a problem. Everything was cleared up by the time they were ready to roll.
Apparently, a man had been killed in an altercation on one of the trains ahead of us. He would never get where he was going. That incident is what delayed all of the trains going into the city. Sometimes the road home is smooth. Sometimes it’s rough. At least I made it.